Humanism vs Atheism vs Secularism: Key Differences
These three words are often used as if they meant the same thing. They do not. In the debate over humanism vs atheism, for instance, people frequently assume that every humanist is an atheist and every atheist a humanist, and that “secular” is just a polite way of saying either. Untangling the terms helps in conversation, in campaigning and in working out where you stand yourself.
The short version
- Atheism is about belief in gods: an atheist does not hold one.
- Humanism is a broader life stance: a view about how to find truth, how to live ethically and what gives life meaning, without appeal to the supernatural.
- Secularism is about how society and the state should be organised: with a separation between religion and public institutions and equal treatment of people of all beliefs.
One is a position on a question, one is a philosophy of life and one is a principle of governance. They can overlap, but none is a stand-in for the others.
Quick comparison table
| Atheism | Humanism | Secularism | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | Lack of belief in gods | A non-religious philosophy of life | A principle about religion and the state |
| Main question | Is there a god? | How should we live and find truth? | How should public life be organised? |
| Applies to | Individual belief | Individual ethics and outlook | Laws, institutions, public policy |
| Includes positive values? | Not by itself | Yes: reason, empathy, human dignity | A commitment to freedom of belief and neutrality |
| Requires non-belief? | Yes, by definition | Generally yes (non-theistic) | No: many religious people support it |
Atheism: a position on one question
The word comes from the Greek for “without god”. Atheism, in its broadest sense, is the absence of belief in any gods. People use it in slightly different ways:
- Some use it to mean actively believing that no gods exist.
- Others use it more loosely to mean simply not believing, without claiming certainty.
That is why you will hear terms such as “weak” or “strong” atheism, or hear people call themselves agnostic atheists. Agnosticism, by the way, concerns knowledge: an agnostic says they do not know, or that it cannot be known, whether a god exists. Agnosticism and atheism are not opposites; someone can be both.
What atheism does not tell you is how a person thinks about ethics, politics, meaning or science. Atheists include people of widely different views. Being an atheist describes what you lack, not what you hold.
Humanism: a way of living without gods
Humanism starts from the same place on the god question, since most humanists are atheists or agnostics, but then goes further. It affirms certain things:
- that reason and evidence are our best guides to knowledge;
- that morality is based on human empathy, experience and shared wellbeing;
- that individuals have dignity and rights;
- that this life is the one we can be sure of, and we should make the most of it, together.
Humanism also has a history of organisations, celebrations and community life, from discussion groups to non-religious ceremonies. Our introduction to what humanism is gives a fuller picture.
You can be an atheist without being a humanist. Someone might reject belief in gods while holding views that humanists would find incompatible, for example an indifference to human rights or a belief in astrology or other unevidenced claims. Conversely, the word “humanist” has historically been used in other ways, for example in Renaissance scholarship, so context matters.
Secularism: a principle for public life
Secularism is not about what individuals believe; it is about how a society arranges itself. In broad terms, it advocates that:
- the state should be neutral between religions and between religion and non-religion;
- laws and public services should not privilege one belief system;
- people should be free to practise a faith, change it or have none, without discrimination.
Secularism comes in different forms around the world. Some countries have a strict separation between religion and state, while others have an established church or religious symbols in public institutions yet still protect freedom of belief.
Importantly, many religious people are secularists. They may value a neutral state because it protects their own freedom to worship and prevents any one group from imposing its views. This is a key difference from atheism and humanism: a person of faith can support secularism wholeheartedly.
How the three overlap
Think of three circles that partly intersect.
- A humanist is typically also an atheist or agnostic, and typically supports a secular state.
- An atheist may or may not be a humanist, and may or may not care about secularism.
- A secularist might be a believer, a humanist, an atheist or someone who has never considered the question.
Here are some quick examples:
- A religious person who campaigns for the equal treatment of all faiths and none: secularist, not atheist or humanist.
- Someone who simply does not believe in gods and has not thought much beyond that: atheist, not necessarily a humanist or an activist for secularism.
- Someone who is non-religious, values evidence-based ethics, runs a local discussion group and supports state neutrality: all three.
Related terms worth knowing
- Agnosticism: the view that the existence of gods is unknown or unknowable.
- Freethought: the principle of forming opinions through reason and evidence instead of authority or tradition; a broad tradition within which many humanists, atheists and secularists see themselves.
- Secular humanism: a term often used in North America for non-religious humanism.
- Non-religious or “nones”: a catch-all for people who do not identify with a religion, including those who hold some spiritual or supernatural beliefs.
- Anti-theism: active opposition to religion, which is a stronger stance than atheism and not shared by all atheists.
- Rationalism, scepticism: approaches that emphasise reason and evidence, overlapping with, but not identical to, humanism.
Why the distinction matters
For conversation. Using the right term avoids needless arguments. A believer who hears “secularism” as “anti-religion” will react very differently from one who understands it as “fairness for everyone”.
For policy. Debates about schools, ceremonies, public prayer or blasphemy laws are about secularism, not about whether gods exist. Treating them as a fight between belief and unbelief obscures the real issues.
For identity. If you are trying to describe your own outlook, picking the term that fits is more satisfying than inheriting a label. Some people prefer “humanist” because it says what they stand for, not just what they reject.
For community. People looking for company may find that humanist or freethought groups welcome atheists, agnostics and curious believers alike, while political secularist groups may focus on policy campaigns.
Which label fits you?
Try these prompts:
- Do you believe in a god or gods? If no or unsure, “atheist” or “agnostic” may apply.
- Do you have a positive philosophy of how to live that rests on reason and compassion? If so, “humanist” may fit.
- Do you think the state should treat all beliefs equally and keep religion out of government? If so, you probably support secularism, whatever your personal beliefs.
You can answer yes to some and no to others. You are not required to adopt any label; they are tools for explaining yourself, not boxes to be locked in.
Is Humanism a Religion? Common Questions Answered
FAQs
Can you be a humanist and believe in God?
In the modern organised sense, humanism is non-theistic, so most humanists do not. Some religious people share humanist values, but they typically describe their outlook differently.
Is secularism anti-religion?
No. Secularism, properly understood, protects freedom of religion as well as freedom from it by keeping the state neutral. Some people confuse it with hostility to religion, but the two are different.
Are all atheists humanists?
No. Atheism concerns belief in gods only. Atheists hold a variety of ethical and political views, and many have no interest in humanist organisations.
Is agnosticism a middle ground between theism and atheism?
Not exactly. Agnosticism is about knowledge, while theism and atheism are about belief. Someone can be an agnostic theist or an agnostic atheist.
Conclusion
Atheism answers one question about gods. Humanism builds a whole outlook on top of a non-religious foundation. Secularism is a principle about how to share a society fairly. Keep the three apart and you will find conversations clearer and your own thinking more precise.